2013 Team Outlook: Miami Dolphins
WR Rishard Matthews, TEN - Not Draft Worthy
If you're looking this far down Miami's depth chart for a receiver then it is quite possible your fantasy season is over. Matthews had just 11 receptions for 151 yards in his rookie season. Simply put, there's no reason a fantasy owner should be looking at Matthews. There are too many receivers ahead of him on the depth chart and too many questions surrounding Miami's run and pass game.
WR Armon Binns, --- - Not Draft Worthy
In his rookie season, Binns pulled in 24 receptions for 277 yards with one touchdown while playing in 11 games for the Bengals and Dolphins. With numbers like these, fantasy owners need to stay as far away as possible. Unless someone ahead of Binns suffers a season ending injury, there is little value to be had here.
WR Brandon Gibson, NE - Low Potential
Update (10/21): Gibson has had a respectible start to the season. Through six games the fifth year man out of Washington has nearly as many yards a Mike Wallace and twice as many touchdowns. Sure he doesn't have the big name but we're talking stats here not image. Gibson is getting the job done on a more consistent basis than Wallace. Fantasy owners looking for someone to fill a bye week opening or an injury may want to take a look Gibson's way.
Profile: Gibson had the best season of his 4 year career last year pulling in 51 receptions for 691 yards and scoring 5 touchdowns. All of this was while playing with Sam Bradford and the St. Louis Rams. Now in Miami, Gibson will need to learn a new offense and adjust to playing with a new quarterback. Brandon has the skills to take over the number two role, but his lack of familiarity with the offense will likely set him back as the season begins. Until we see some on the field consistency, it is best to hold off on drafting Gibson.
WR Brian Hartline, --- - Bye Week Fill-in
Update (10/21): For the most part Hartline's performance this season has been very consistent. Week in and week out he has 3-5 receptions for 50-70 yards with an occassional touchdown or high yardage game. If you're looking for a flex start then Hartline could be a nice fit. If nothing else at least you can count on five or six points with the possiblilty of eleven or twelve.
Profile: From time to time Hartline will go nuts (see week 4 last season), but performances like that are few and far between. Most weeks Brian will score you 5-7 points, so unless you're looking for a bye week fill-in there's just not enough value here. We'd like to see more from Hartline, but the fact remains there are too many uncertainties surrounding Tannehill and the run game for anyone to feel comfortable starting Hartline on a weekly basis.
TE Charles Clay, BUF - Deep-league Only
Update (10/21): Up till last week Clay was a nice bye week fill-in for fantasy owners and even last week's game wasn't all that bad. For the third week in a row Clay found the end zone. Unfortunately just when it looked like Clay was going to be fantasy worthy week in and week out he has just one reception on three targets. This could have been a fluke or it could be a sign of things to come. Owners should use caution when starting Clay these next few weeks. If Clay is only seeing two or three targets it may be time to cut him loose.
Profile: On Tuesday, OC Mike Sherman said if the season started this week Clay would be the Dolphins' starting TE. We're not sure that's how things will play out over the next few weeks, so it is probably best to hold off on drafting one of Miami's tight ends.
TE Dion Sims, CHI - Deep-league Only
Update (8/21): At this point just who starts at TE for Miami week one is anyone's guess. On Tuesday OC Mike Sherman said if the season started this week they would go with H-Back Charles Clay, using him on the line, in the backfield and split out as pass receiver. At this point (until we see how the Dolphins plan to fill the void left by Keller), it may be best to avoid Miami's tight end on draft day.
It appears the rookie out of Michigan State will start the season opposite Keller in Miami's offense. At 6'5" and 285 lbs., it is likely Sims will be used as a blocking tight end and see very little action in the passing game. Should something happen to Keller, it is more likely we would see fullback Charles Clay line up as the receiving tight end than Sims. There is little value to be had here at this time.
Update: With the injury to Tight End Dustin Keller, somebody has to step up for the Dolphins. Rookie Dion Sims makes the most sense to us to fill in for Keller. He's had a good preseason and will need to step up and fill some pretty big shoes. Other names in the mix: H-Back Charles Clay. The Dolphins have primarily been using him as a fullback so there will be an adjustment period. Second year tight end Michael Egnew disappointed the team last season must improve his run blocking or he will never find his way on the field.