Why The Vikings Should Trade The #3 Pick

Football > Commentary > Why The Vikings Should Trade The #3 Pick

Why The Vikings Should Trade The #3 Pick

It is a foregone conclusion that Andrew Luck and Robert Griffin III will be the first 2 players taken in the NFL Draft in two weeks. The debate starts at the #3 pick. The Minnesota Vikings currently hold that pick. Do they stay with the pick or trade out of that spot? Ryan Tannehill @ryantannehill1 has been rising up every team's draft boards and is threatening to crack the top 5, maybe even the top 3 picks for the NFL Draft. The Vikings used a first round pick last year on Christian Ponder and seem willing to give him the reigns to the offense for at least one more year. With that in mind, we will look at the possible options for the Vikings during the draft.

Keep the pick

The need for a left offensive tackle is very large for the Minnesota Vikings. They let Bryant McKinnie go last year after he showed up over 370 pounds. The need was very evident last year as the Vikings struggled to protect the quarterback all year. Donovan McNabb, Christian Ponder, & Joe Webb all had to get rid of the ball early, take a sack, or scramble for their life. The addition of Matt Kalil from USC would greatly solidify the blind side of the quarterback for the next 10 years. Kalil is the highest rated tackle to come out of college since Joe Thomas for the Cleveland Browns – he is an annual Pro-Bowl selection.

Trade with Cleveland Browns

It seems like an odd situation when a team may trade up 1 spot in the draft, but that may happen this year with the Cleveland Browns. The Browns have holes at every position on the roster and know that Colt McCoy is not the answer for the future of the franchise. The Browns own the #4 pick in the draft and many think they would be happy to draft running back Trent Richardson from Alabama with the pick. If you study all of the great running backs in the NFL, most have not won a Super Bowl. LaDainian Tomlinson, Adrian Peterson, Ray Rice, LeSean McCoy, Maurice Jones-Drew are all current players who are considered great running backs and have not won a Super Bowl. The need to have a great quarterback is becoming more evident every day for a team to have a chance at a World Championship.

The Browns could trade up with the Vikings to take Ryan Tannehill at the #3 spot. What would they have to give up?? The answer has a lot to do with the Miami Dolphins who pick at #8. If they offer their 2nd first round pick, #22 overall, the Vikings could find a very decent wide receiver and STILL draft Matt Kalil to solidify the offensive line. If it is the 2nd round pick, #37 overall, The Vikings could fulfill a need at wide receiver with the likes of Stephen Hill out of out of Georgia Tech, Rueben Randle @RuebenRandle out of LSU or Alshon Jeffrey out of South Carolina. They could also look at the cornerback position with Janoris Jenkins from North Alabama or Alfonso Dennard from Nebraska. In this scenario the Vikings would be picking at #35 & #37. If it is a 3rd round pick, #67 overall, the Vikings could address several needs like those listed above or look at Guard Amini Silatolu from Midwestern State or Kelechi Osemele from Iowa State. They could also look at Safety George Iloka from Boise State.

Trade with Miami Dolphins

This has been a terrible off-season for the Miami Dolphins losing their best wide receiver in a trade and their top quarterback in free agency. The Dolphins have not been able to sign any significant free agents either and look to be a team in turmoil. The need of a quarterback is vital for a team desperate for an identity and a reason for the fans to have a glimmer of hope. Like the Browns above, Ryan Tannehill would be the target for Miami to trade up to the #3 spot. The Dolphins have the #8 pick in the draft and would have to put together a package better then the Browns would offer.

It has been rumored by former Indianapolis Colts GM and current ESPN analyst Bill Polian that the Dolphins could offer a swap of picks in the 1st as well as their 2nd and 3rd round picks, numbers 42 & 72 respectively. In this scenario the Vikings can still sign an offensive tackle like Riley Reiff or wide receiver like Michael Floyd @MichaelMFloyd and also fill their other need areas at cornerback, guard, and safety all by the 3rd round. It is not that far of a stretch that Tackle Matt Kalil from USC could still be available. Look at the scenario below:

#3 Miami Dolphins – Quarterback Ryan Tannehill
#4 Cleveland Browns – Running Back Trent Richardson
#5 Tampa Bay Buccaneers – Cornerback Morris Claiborne
#6 St Louis Rams – Wide Receiver Justin Blackmon @JustBlack81
#7 Jacksonville Jaguars – Wide Receiver Michael Floyd

General Manager Rick Spielman has stated that the Vikings will build through the draft. The trading of the 3rd overall pick this year will accomplish that in a big hurry if the draft falls according to the above scenarios. Right now the Vikings have 10 picks in the draft this year. They may have 1 or 2 more, and those would be of the higher variety, to make this team more competitive in a hurry.

Related Posts

No Tweetbacks


    I have enjoyed Latske and his form of sarcasm but yet to the point on the Viks. His insight and knowledge on the subject is refreshing because he is direct, yet "skirts" the ripping at the same time. We have all gone to H--- and back with them, but are still fans. Thanks Todd........

    Posted by:
    Report Abuse
    KevinattheTap 04/13/12 11:06 PM

    Thanks for the support Kevin. I try to make my column entertaining and insightful. Your comments help me to keep going in that direction. Thanks for reading!!

    Posted by:
    Todd Latzke 04/14/12 12:02 PM

    A very interesting article. I get the feeling that come draft day that Minnesota won't be able to deal the pick. The three spot could be a little too high for a team to go after Tannehill, and the Dolphins may feel comfortable enough at 8th to sit and wait for him. Of course after the Ted Ginn Jr selection that Miami pulled off a few years ago, the debacle that has been their 2012 off-season so far, there is no telling what they may be thinking. I'm guessing the Browns are set to pull the trigger on Richardson, just because of how bare the running back position shelf is for the Browns. On the bright side, as you covered, there is nothing wrong with the Vikings getting the best tackle in this years draft, to protect their QB of the future. Then they can bolster the receiving corps with the 35th overall pick. Ideally, a Randle, Hill or Jeffery are all on the board there and Harvin gets some much needed help. Great read, really enjoyed it.

    Posted by:
    Walton Spurlin 04/22/12 10:43 AM

    Thanks for the feedback Walton. The #3 pick is where the uncertainty starts for the draft, still many rumors floating around. Hope you enjoy the draft and thanks for reading!!

    Posted by:
    Todd Latzke 04/23/12 10:29 AM

    The Vikings are certainly keeping every one in suspense as draft time approaches. Of course, as the draft gets closer, the misinformation pipeline really heats up. It sounds like they may have multiple suitors for the #3 pick, if we can believe what the 'pundits' are reporting, that is. Very excited to see how this all plays out.

    Posted by:
    Walton Spurlin 04/26/12 04:54 PM

    I hate to say "I told you so", but it looks like I was right on the money here. As a Viking fan I am happy that they traded back up into the 1st round again to get a safety that they needed. I hope that they use the other picks as wisely!!

    Posted by:
    Todd Latzke 04/27/12 12:04 AM

    You must login in order to comment:

    If you do not have an account yet, register here -- it's free

    Warning: You don't have cookies enabled in your internet broswer. Without cookies, you will not be able to login. Some web browsers allow cookies to be managed on a per-site basis.